This is the Peer Review page for the manuscript
  • Reference:
  • ​Type:
  • Submission date:
  • Authors can track their manuscript here
  • Peer Reviewers can download the manuscript here  
Who has access to this page?
  • The corresponding author
  • Any co-authors nominated by the corresponding author
  • The EBM handling Peer Review
  • Peer Reviewers nominated by the EBM
  • The JDR Editorial office
  • No-one else ​

Peer Review and MS Status

JDR operates a staged Peer Review (details). The highlighted text shows the progress of the manuscript:
  • Manuscript received
  • Submitted to Validation Assessment
  • Submitted to Progression Assessment
  • Submitted to Peer Review
  • Accepted by  JDR

The highlighted text shows the current status of the manuscript:
  • With us for assessment
  • With you for revision
  • Accepted and with CUP for printing and publishing
  • Rejected and returned to you

Manuscript justification

These are the justification statements that the authors supplied in support of publication: 

Peer Reviewer Instructions

  • Note the justification statements
  • Download the original or latest revision of the manuscript
  • If relevant, download earlier reviews
  • Once you are ready,. go to Perform Peer Review and follow the instructions  
 Picture
We shall contact the corresponding author by email when there are updates to this page
Picture
If you have a question for us please click the image to access the enquiry form

Progress Reports

As the manuscript progresses through Peer Review, reports will appear. The currently available documents are here: