​IMPORTANT:

• ​please ONLY use this form for a revised version of a manuscript that YOU have previously Peer Reviewed
• manuscripts are sometimes revised to address EBM concerns, and in this case you should use the standard report form ​

Thank you for Peer Reviewing this manuscript for JDR. A revised version of the manuscript has now been submitted. Could you please assess the revision and tell us if it is now acceptable for publication. Thank you!  

Please conduct the assessment as quickly as possible, preferably within two weeks of receipt

The assessment decision has three options: 

• The authors have satisfied my concerns; the manuscript is now acceptable for publication 
• The authors have partially satisfied my concerns, but further revision is necessary
• The authors have failed to satisfy my concerns. the manuscript should be rejected

 
Guidance for Authors
If you have chosen to recommend further revision or rejection, you should use the Guidance for Authors to explain why you came to this decision. Please state your reasons clearly and succinctly.





 

















Please remember to press the submit button when you have finished your Assessment. You will then see a "Thank you" screen. If you do not see this, the submission has failed, probably because you have not filled in all of the compulsory fields. Find the error and correct it, then press submit again. ​Your report will be available online anonymously to the Authors, you and the EBM 

.  .